We recommend upgrading to Fromm Gold or FirstMate from Blue Buffalo.

Blue Buffalo, for a national brand, has a decent ingredient panel, they've just gotten too expensive over the last couple of years.

Fromm Gold is a Wisconsin family-owned company that cost 43 cents less per pound and has a similar ingredient panel with a touch more protein.

FirstMate is a low-glycemic, limited ingredient diet with a high protein content from meat. For 20 cents less per pound you are getting over 100 more kcals per cup, thus you will feed about 20% less than Blue Buffalo.